Spoiler alert! This article reveals major moments from Naruto Shippuden, including details about Itachi Uchiha, Sasuke, and the Uchiha clan massacre.
What if one of the most hated characters in Naruto was never the monster his own brother believed him to be?
For most of Naruto Shippuden, Sasuke Uchiha lives for a single goal: killing Itachi, the older brother who wiped out almost the entire Uchiha clan and left just one person alive to carry that pain.
To Sasuke, there was no mystery. Itachi was a cold-blooded killer who destroyed his family and turned his childhood into a nightmare. Revenge looked like the only road left.
But everything takes a different turn when the truth about Itachi is finally revealed.
In my opinion, the biggest lie ever told in Naruto isn’t just a false story about the Uchiha massacre. It’s a lie that turned the love between two brothers into hatred and made Sasuke question everything he believed in.
And here’s the thing: that reveal doesn’t make the situation as simple as it sounds. Knowing why Itachi did what he did doesn’t mean he made the right choices.
The Lie That Turned Sasuke Into an Avenger
To see why the truth about Itachi hits so hard, we have to go back to Sasuke’s childhood.
Back then, Itachi was a lot more than just his older brother. Sasuke admired him more than anyone else. Sasuke wanted to earn his family’s respect and prove his worth, but he also had one big dream: to become as strong as Itachi.
That relationship broke apart in a single night, the night of the Uchiha massacre.
When Sasuke found his clan dead, he walked straight into a reality he couldn’t make sense of. And Itachi didn’t just admit he was responsible — he used his power to force his little brother to relive the tragedy through an illusion.
The message was brutal. Sasuke was supposed to hate him, get stronger, and come after him for revenge.
From that moment on, Sasuke’s whole life revolved around one question: how do I beat Itachi?
His hatred didn’t come out of nowhere. It was fed by a version of events that hid the very details he needed to understand what had really happened to his family.
That’s why this lie left such a deep mark. Sasuke didn’t only lose his parents and relatives. He also lost the chance to understand his own past while he was growing up.
Why Did Sasuke Want to Kill Itachi?
The answer seems obvious: Itachi killed his family.
But there’s an emotional layer that makes this relationship far more tragic. Sasuke wasn’t hating some random enemy. He hated the person he admired, someone he’d wanted to be close to and whose approval he’d been chasing since he was a kid.
That contradiction follows him for most of the series.
His hunger for power ties directly back to the promise he made himself: become strong enough to kill his brother. Even his bond with Naruto, and his time on Team 7, gets pulled into that goal.
Look at the story from this angle and you realize that Itachi’s lie didn’t stay locked in that one night. It changed how Sasuke saw other people, shaped his decisions, and left its mark on everything he did afterward.
The Truth Behind the Uchiha Massacre: What Really Happened?
The story Sasuke knew painted Itachi as the man behind an atrocity driven by personal reasons. The reality, revealed later in Naruto Shippuden, involves a much larger political conflict.
The relationship between the Uchiha clan and the Hidden Leaf Village was getting worse and worse, and tensions kept climbing. After the suspicion and distrust that followed the Nine-Tails attack, clan members found themselves isolated and constantly watched by Konoha’s authorities.
Things escalated into a coup d’état plan. If it had gone through, the coup could have triggered a civil war and pushed the conflict between the Uchiha and the village itself even further.
Itachi, a shinobi tied to the clan who also had connections inside Konoha’s power structure, ended up trapped right in the middle of that fight.
The Role of Danzo and the Hidden Leaf
This is where events take an even darker turn.
Danzo Shimura, one of the people behind some of the most extreme decisions in Konoha’s leadership, pressured Itachi to eliminate the clan and stop the coup. Itachi received the mission in a situation where the only alternative on the table was an even bigger tragedy.
He agreed to carry out the massacre, but he made one decisive choice: he spared Sasuke.
Knowing this changes how we see Itachi’s actions, but it doesn’t erase his responsibility for what he did. He took part directly in the deaths of people from his own clan, while the political structures that helped cause the tragedy share the blame too.
The truth behind the Uchiha massacre isn’t just a family secret. It exposes what happens when a village tries to solve a political conflict with a brutal decision.
That’s exactly what makes the story so compelling: the problem can’t be explained by one person’s evil alone.
Why Did Itachi Let His Own Brother Hate Him?
One of the most painful questions in this story is: did Itachi love Sasuke?
The answer is yes. The bond between them is at the core of Itachi’s entire story. But the way he tried to protect his brother was full of extreme, contradictory choices.
By sparing Sasuke, Itachi saved his life. But instead of telling him the truth, he let Sasuke grow up believing he had to kill his brother to make up for the past.
He also tried to steer Sasuke’s growth through hatred, figuring that revenge would make him strong enough to stand across from him and defeat him.
In Itachi’s warped way of seeing things, the plan had its own logic. The emotional cost, though, was enormous.
Was Itachi a Hero or a Villain?
This question doesn’t have a satisfying answer if you try to squeeze the character into just one of those boxes.
Itachi made decisions to protect Sasuke and stop the conflict in Konoha from exploding into an even bigger war. At the same time, he manipulated his brother, hid crucial information, and made choices that added to his suffering.
He doesn’t have to be a flawless hero for his sacrifices to be recognized. And understanding his motives doesn’t require ignoring the harm he caused.
The way I read it, Itachi’s tragedy is that he tried to protect the person he loved most using methods that hurt that person deeply.
Itachi believed that by hiding the truth from Sasuke, he could steer his brother’s future and decide what he should know. The problem is that people aren’t pieces in someone’s plan, and the truth doesn’t stop having consequences just because somebody thinks they’re doing the right thing.
The Reveal That Changed Naruto’s Story
The big turning point comes after Itachi’s death, when Tobi approaches Sasuke and reveals information that contradicts everything he thought he knew about his brother.
Until then, Sasuke believed he’d finished his revenge. He’d fought Itachi and finally reached the goal he’d carried since childhood.
But finding out that Itachi didn’t act out of simple cruelty turns his victory into an identity crisis.
If his brother wasn’t quite the monster he’d imagined, what did everything Sasuke had fought for actually mean?
The reveal also redirects his anger. Sasuke starts looking at Konoha differently, because he learns that the village’s leadership played a part in the situation that led to the massacre.
What Did Tobi Reveal About Itachi?
The reveal presents Itachi as someone who carried the weight of a devastating political decision alone, saving Sasuke’s life while hiding the real circumstances of the massacre from him.
That doesn’t mean we should swallow every word Tobi says. He has his own agenda, and he uses the information to influence Sasuke.
Still, later events and the details of Itachi’s mission confirm that the story was far more complicated than Sasuke ever imagined.
The truth shatters the image he had of his brother, but it doesn’t wipe out the suffering he went through. If anything, it forces Sasuke to reinterpret his entire life.
The person Sasuke had spent years wanting to kill was also someone who had always loved him. And the village that was supposed to protect its people was caught up in the tragedy that destroyed his family.
It’s hard to think of a reveal that changes a character’s direction this deeply.
Did Itachi Make the Right Call, or Did His Lies Make Sasuke’s Pain Worse?
This is the point that, to me, makes this story so much more interesting than a simple plot twist.
If Itachi wanted to protect Sasuke, why pick a strategy that would feed so much hatred? Why not tell Sasuke the truth and let him reach his own conclusions?
Itachi may have believed that hiding the truth would spare Sasuke from the political fallout of the Uchiha massacre. It’s easy to understand why he worried that telling the truth might put his little brother at risk.
But there’s a difference between protecting someone and deciding, on your own, which reality they get to know.
Sasuke grew up with a distorted view of his own past. His quest for revenge damaged his relationships with Naruto, Sakura, and the rest of his teammates. Later, the reveal led him to turn on the Hidden Leaf Village itself and consider new paths of violence.
It wouldn’t be fair to pin every one of Sasuke’s decisions on Itachi alone. Sasuke makes his own choices, and what happens later is shaped by other characters and circumstances too.
Even so, Itachi’s lie was a decisive piece in how Sasuke’s path took shape.
And there’s one more important detail: when Itachi returns during the Fourth Great Ninja War, he admits he should have trusted Sasuke more and shared the truth with him. Rather than trying to control his brother’s future, he realizes he should have been honest with him and let him make his own choices.
That admission only deepens his tragedy. Itachi spent so long trying to steer Sasuke’s fate that he only understood the limits of that strategy when it was too late to fix the past the way he’d wanted.
Meaning to protect someone doesn’t guarantee your choices actually protect them. That’s one of the most powerful ideas you can take from the bond between these two brothers.
So, Was This the Biggest Lie Ever Told in Naruto?
In my opinion, yes — especially when you think about the impact it had on Sasuke’s life and on how audiences came to understand Itachi.
The lie didn’t stop at hiding who was responsible and what really happened during the Uchiha massacre. It turned brotherly love into hatred, sent Sasuke chasing revenge for years, and, after the truth came out, changed how he saw the very village where he was born.
Few reveals in Naruto change the meaning of events we’ve followed for so long this profoundly.
The most striking part is that the truth doesn’t turn Itachi into someone without flaws. More than anything, it shows just how much Itachi loved Sasuke, while also making it clear how many mistakes he made trying to protect him.
That’s exactly why the story hurts so much. Itachi tried to protect his brother, but he didn’t trust him enough to let him know the truth. Sasuke, meanwhile, spent years trying to destroy the man he thought was responsible for all his pain, with no idea what had really happened.
In the end, the biggest lie in Naruto wasn’t just the false version of one terrible night. It was the belief that Sasuke had to hate his own brother to grow strong and find his path.
So what do you think? Did Itachi do what he had to do to protect Sasuke, or should he have told him the truth from the start?
Cover image: Naruto © Masashi Kishimoto / Shueisha
